July 28

Electric Tea Kettle Vs. Stovetop Kettle – Which one to buy?

Looking for a new kettle but are stuck in between an electric tea kettle vs. stovetop? Then keep reading.

Although boiling water for a cup of tea sounds like a seemingly simple task, you can find yourself overwhelmed by the number of options when shopping for a tea kettle. Water temperature is a crucial element for brewing a tasty cup of tea since pouring scorching water on a delicate tea can result in a bitter drink.

There are two options you need to consider, an electric tea kettle or a traditional stovetop kettle. Which one to choose will depend on your personal preference. However, if you are confused and need help to make up your mind, go through this article till the end to get all the necessary information that will help you make the decision.

Difference between Electric Tea Kettle and Stovetop Kettle

Although both of them appear to do the same work, i.e., heat water. The underlying distinction between them is in the way they heat water.

A stovetop kettle needs an outside heat source to act, as the name says. You may find it interesting to know that people choose this kind of stovetop in 90 percent of the cases.

On the other hand, electric kettles need a power supply to boil water and do not need an external heat source. Another difference is that while a stovetop kettle makes a rolling boil perfect and can really heat the water above the boiling point, electric kettles provide various choices that the stovetop cannot match.

For example, many electric kettles give several heat adjustments, which means you have full control and precision when preparing the water for your tea. You have a water gauge, and water is boiled evenly & faster.

All you need to know about a Stovetop Kettle!

The Stove kettle has been used for a very long time by people and is considered the traditional way of making coffee or tea. Stovetops are capable of heating water above the boiling point.

Benefits of the stovetop kettles:

  1. Affordability: Stove kettles come at a lower price. Which makes them the perfect option for those of you looking to stay within a budget.
  1. Beautiful designs: Stovetop kettles as well as electric kettles come in variety of designs and colors, but still, stovetop kettles have more variety in their colours, designs and shapes. Many shapes, materials, and colors of kettles are available that appears fabulous and functions well.
  1. Works in every condition: Electric kettles depend upon electricity .They can’t work during power cuts, or during your outdoor activities like camping or picnics. Whereas a stovetop kettle can work on any stove otherwise you can even put it on a campfire.

Here are some pros and cons you must know about stovetop before you consider buying it:

Pros

  • Elegant design and can easily blend
  • Capable of creating six cups of tea at a time
  • It is made from high-quality steel
  • Pleasantly whistles when water is boiling
  • Affordable price
  • A secure and stay cool handle
  • It comes with a lifetime warranty
  • Available in many colors

Cons

  • Narrow opening
  • It doesn’t have an equivalent level of flexibility as an electric kettle.
  • Comparatively slow to heat
  • It can only be used where there’s an external heat source.

Everything about the Electric Kettle!

Although the electric kettle requires electricity, it still is more convenient than a stove kettle. That’s because these kettles have features that make them more convenient than their counterparts. Such as temperature control and auto shut off.

Convenience and portability are the hallmarks of electric kettles. An electric kettle consists of a heating element at the bottom.

Here are few advantages of using an electric tea kettle:

  1. Time-saving: Electric kettles save more time as compared to stovetop kettles. These high voltage kettles take not more than a few minutes to heat water and make it reach its boiling point.
  1. Portability:  Unlike stovetop kettles, electric kettles don’t depend upon the stove that’s usually found only in a kitchen. The best part of having an electrical kettle is that you simply can place it wherever you are.  All you’ve got to do is to connect the kettle to an electric plug and the rest is done. So electric kettles are more portable and can work anywhere with a wall socket.
  1. Temperature control: Technology has made electric kettles way too smarter than the standard stovetop kettle. Mere boiling water isn’t enough. Some teas are too sensitive to be boiled, and their authentic flavor and taste could also be destroyed with over boiling.

What an electric kettle does lately is to offer accurate temperature control. You can heat water at your required temperature and extract the real flavor of tea, coffee, white tea, or other drinks.

  1. Energy-efficient: Stovetop kettles are less energy efficient as compared to electric kettles. The component below the kettle directly heats the water, and no electricity is lost. On the stovetop, the flames surround the kettles and warm the air around also because of the water inside. More energy is wasted this manner, and thus electric kettles save more energy.
  1. Auto shutoff: Electric kettles accompany an auto-shutoff system. An electrical kettle immediately shutoff when water reaches the specified temperature. This feature not only saves energy but also prevents overheating of water.

Just remember that an electric kettle with a better wattage will generally heat water faster than that with a lower wattage.

Pros

  • Heat water fast with high watt unit
  • Distinguished  design
  • Temperature control
  • Ability to keep the water warm

Cons

  • It does not come with a temperature control feature
  • Can be harder to wash due to the heating element

So Which is better – Electric tea kettle vs Stovetop?

Here is a table to help you compare electric kettles and stovetop kettles so you’ll see which appliance could be right for you. It’s essential to recollect that both the appliances provide an equivalent outcome, boiled water. And no matter whether you boil the water in an electric kettle or a stovetop kettle, the water will taste equivalent and be ready to reach equivalent temperatures.

 Electric KettleStovetop Kettle
PowerElectricGas/flame
Speed of boiling100-200 seconds200-500  seconds
Built-in thermometerSometimesNo
Auto shut offYesNo
Cost of appliance$10 – $200$30 – $200
Cost to run the appliance$0.02 per boil$0.05 per boil  

Suppose the only thing you are looking for in a kettle is to raise the water temperature as high as possible. In that case, you should know that the stove kettle can boil water that is even hotter than the boiling point, which is why numerous people wish to use them for boiling water for their delicious coffee or for steeping tea. And in case a comparison is made between an electric kettle and a stove kettle based just on this requirement of boiling water, then the stove kettle is the winner here.

But stove kettle has various disadvantages or cons, so some people prefer to leave instead and buy an electric kettle for their kitchen rather than a stove kettle. And this is one aspect for which the electric kettle is considered superior in portability and convenience.

Is Electric Kettle Harmful to your Health?

An electric kettle is of no harm if we choose a good quality one. It is a plastic kettle loaded with BPA chemicals and is harmful to people and their health because plastic quickly leaks out when the temperature rises and raises health concerns. The BPA is out there in polycarbonate that’s the staple of plastic.

This chemical could create problems for the unborn child, and sometimes it becomes the main explanation for obesity in children. If you ever go for buying an electric kettle or something else made of plastic, make sure you know the quality of products used in the material to be of no harm to you after you use it.

But on the other hand, the best thing about plastic kettles is their price. They’re generally very cheap, lightweight, and can be held anywhere without stress about accidental falls and blows.

Factors to Consider While Buying a Kettle:

So how does one choose the foremost suitable kettle? One of the foremost important considerations is to see the device’s capacity, how hot you would like your water to be, and how fast the water boils. If you are doing all that, then you ought to be ready to choose the kettle that’s right for you with no problem. We must know various factors before deciding which one to buy. Here are few factors you should consider before buying a kettle:

  • Easy to pour
  • The kettle’s capacity
  • How easily it can be cleaned
  • Cost
  • Durability
  • Materials

Winding Up

The best kettle you should purchase for yourself should depend upon your needs and what your use is. To conclude, an electric kettle is worth more buying as it is easy to use compared to a stovetop kettle that needs less time to boil. Looking at the pros and cons, it clearly seems that an electric kettle wins the fight, and you should definitely go for an electric kettle if you ever think about buying a kettle for your kitchen requirements.

About the author

I'm Su, a tea enthusiast, long-term traveler, business strategist, and furry mom of two. I'm on this journey to learn the "right" and the "wrong" ways to tea, to ask the "dumb" questions, to hear the stories about people & their connection to tea & to find ways to incorporate it into my life. The Tea Tasting Club is all about tea & product reviews, tea recipes, and providing helpful tea information.


Tags


You may also like

The History of High Tea

The History of High Tea
Leave a Reply
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Join the club to get exclusive tea content!